General

- 100% game progression
- High honor Arthur’s death
- $49k, Max honor, Max hair & beard length, Perfect weight
- All missions with Gold Medal
- All side missions / honor missions completed
- All drawings on map (including unobtainable Northern Pike legendary fish drawing)
- Well made journal with all entries including all rare Arthur’s entries (New Austin, Dino Bones, Painting Cabin...)
- All cheat codes unlocked

Compendium

- All animals have been studied, tracked, killed and skinned at least once (including all mangy animals)
- All equipments owned
- All fishes have been caught at least once with the correct bait
- All gangs camps have been found, all bounties captured, hideouts found, ambushes and unique encounters done
- All plants have been picked, tasted and used in a recipe at least once
- All horses common / uncommon coats have been ridden and studied, level 4 bonding reached for each race
- All weapons discovered
- All cigarette cards discovered

Weapons

- All weapons owned and fully upgraded
- All weapons with max familiarity
- Double Lancaster (the one with diamond logo is John's Lancaster)
- Double Bolt Action Rifle
- Double John's Cattleman
- Double Algernon Revolver
- Double Midnight's Pistol
- Cattleman with diamond logo has the unique "Hero Pearl Grip"
- Double-Action Revolver with diamond logo has the unique "Gunslinger Ebony Grip"
- Electrostatic detector

Horses (all level 4 bonding)

- Rachel
- Buell
- Mahogany Bay Tennessee Walker (Chapter 1 horse)
- Boadicea (Liver Chestnut Hungarian Half-bred), speculated to be Arthur's horse prior to the game's events.
(Note: All Arabian horses are still in the wilderness)

Clothes

- All outfits owned
- All pieces of clothing owned
- All crafted/found/stolen hat
- Nuevo Paraiso outfit + individual clothes (special edition not needed)
- Denim scout jacket (Pearson request)
- Vaquero rider spurs (Dutch request)
- Dirty red union suit (unobtainable legitimately)
- Worn dark denim ranch pants (unobtainable legitimately)
- Yellow range gloves (unobtainable legitimately)
- John's flap cap
- John's gambler hat
- John’s wedding hat (stored on horse, cannot be actually owned in wardrobe)
- Drifter Hat (Uncle request)
- Classic Frock coat (Uncle request)
- Frontier vest (Uncle request)
- Tornado boots (Uncle request)
- The Grizzlies Belt + Holster

Items

- All Letters
- All Notes
- All Newspaper Scraps
- All Business Cards
- All Bounty Posters
- All Photographs
- All Handbills
- All Treasure Maps (including ultimate edition "Le tresor des morts")
- All Books
- All Hunting Requests
- All Drawings
- All Maps
- All Invitations
- All Recipe Pamphlets
- All Rock Carvings Locations
- All Dinosaur Bones Locations
- All Newspapers
- All Cigarette Cards
- All Valuables
- All Keepsakes
- All Watches
- All Trinkets and Talismans (including special edition ones)
- Rare Kits (Jail cell key, Jail cell keys, Sister Calderon's Crucifix)
- Rare Materials (small legendary fishes, legendary animals parts, giant boar tusk…)